Crashcart Start your free trial

HIPAA security for small practices

HIPAA breach notification rules for small practices

Under HIPAA's breach notification rules, a small practice that finds patient information was used or disclosed in a way HIPAA doesn't allow must treat it as a breach unless a written risk assessment of four factors shows a low probability the information was compromised. For a breach of unsecured information, you mail each affected patient within 60 days of discovery and report to HHS within the same 60 days if 500 or more people are affected, or within 60 days after the end of the calendar year if fewer were. Prominent media outlets in a state must be told when more than 500 of its residents are affected. Information encrypted the way HHS specifies is "secured," and losing it triggers none of these notices.

The rules are the HIPAA Breach Notification Rule, 45 CFR 164.400 to 164.414. They sit next to the Security Rule, which the full guide to the HIPAA Security Rule for small practices covers. The steps below follow the order a practice meets them.

Is it a HIPAA breach?

A breach is "the acquisition, access, use, or disclosure of protected health information in a manner not permitted" by the Privacy Rule "which compromises the security or privacy" of the information (45 CFR 164.402). In a small office that covers a misdirected fax or email, a statement mailed to the wrong patient, a hacked email account, ransomware on the server, and a laptop or phone that goes missing.

Three situations are excluded from the definition:

  1. A staff member or other person working under your authority unintentionally looks at or uses patient information in good faith, within the scope of their job, and doesn't use or disclose it further. A front desk employee who opens the wrong chart and closes it is the common case.
  2. Someone authorized to see patient information at your practice inadvertently shares it with someone else authorized at your practice, or in an organized health care arrangement you're part of, and it goes no further.
  3. You have a good faith belief that the person who received the information "would not reasonably have been able to retain" it.

Everything else that breaks the Privacy Rule "is presumed to be a breach" unless you show a low probability of compromise. HHS's Breach Notification Rule page adds that a practice may skip the assessment and notify.

How to do the four-factor risk assessment

164.402 lists the factors the assessment has to cover, at a minimum. For each one, write down what you found.

  1. The nature and extent of the information, "including the types of identifiers and the likelihood of re-identification." A name and appointment time is different from a Social Security number, a diagnosis or a full chart.
  2. The unauthorized person who used the information or received it. Another provider bound by HIPAA is different from a stranger or an attacker.
  3. Whether anyone acquired or viewed the information. A misdirected envelope returned unopened is different from a mailbox an attacker read for a week.
  4. How far the risk has been mitigated. For example, a written confirmation from the wrong recipient that they deleted the email and kept no copy.

Then write the conclusion and who made it. The practice carries the burden of proof that it sent every required notice, or that the incident wasn't a breach (164.414). That documentation falls under the Privacy Rule's retention period of six years (164.530(j)). A "no breach" decision with nothing on paper is hard to defend.

When the 60 days start

The clock starts on the day of discovery, which is the first day the breach is known to your practice or "by exercising reasonable diligence would have been known" (164.404(a)(2)). Your practice knows when any workforce member or agent knows, other than the person who committed the breach. If the hygienist saw the ransom note on Friday and told nobody until Tuesday, the 60 days started Friday.

Sixty days is the outer limit. The rule says notice goes out "without unreasonable delay," so waiting until day 59 with the facts in hand doesn't meet it.

The one exception is law enforcement. If police or federal agents say a notice would impede a criminal investigation, you delay for the time they state in writing, or up to 30 days after an oral statement that you document with the official's name (164.412).

What to tell patients

Each affected patient gets written notice by first-class mail to their last known address, or by email if they've agreed to electronic notice (164.404(d)). You can send more than one letter as you learn more. For a patient you know has died, write to the next of kin or personal representative if you have their address.

The letter must be in plain language and include, to the extent possible:

  1. A brief description of what happened, with the date of the breach and the date you discovered it.
  2. The types of information involved, such as name, Social Security number, date of birth, address, account number or diagnosis.
  3. Steps patients should take to protect themselves.
  4. What your practice is doing to investigate, reduce the harm and prevent it happening again.
  5. How to reach you, which the rule says "shall include a toll-free telephone number, an e-mail address, Web site, or postal address."

When addresses are missing or out of date, substitute notice applies. For fewer than 10 people, another written notice, a phone call or other means will do. For 10 or more, post a notice on your website's home page for 90 days or run it in major print or broadcast media where they live, with a toll-free number that works for at least 90 days. If misuse looks imminent, you may also call patients, on top of the letter.

How to report a breach to HHS

Every breach of unsecured information goes to HHS. Only the deadline changes with size (164.408).

500 or more people. Report at the same time as the patient letters, within 60 days of discovery. HHS posts these on its public list of breaches.

Fewer than 500 people. Keep a log, and report each breach "not later than 60 days after the end of each calendar year" for breaches discovered that year. For breaches discovered in 2026, 60 days after December 31 is March 1, 2027. HHS's breach reporting page says you don't have to wait for the end of the year, and that you "must submit a separate notice for each breach incident." Three small breaches in a year means three filings.

Both go through the HHS breach portal, under File a HIPAA Breach. If you're unsure how many people were affected, HHS says to give an estimate. If you learn more later, file an addendum using the transaction number from your first report.

On October 18, 2026 we opened the portal's form without filing anything and read HHS's 9-page sample of the questions (OMB No. 0945-0003). For a practice reporting its own breach, the form runs across six screens: General, Contact, Breach, Notice of Breach and Actions Taken, Attestation and Summary. We counted 25 fields marked required on that path. What stood out:

  • It asks for start and end dates for both the breach and its discovery, all four marked required.
  • It asks the date patient notice started and its expected end date, both required. File after the letters go out, or once their date is set.
  • "Safeguards in Place Prior to Breach" is required, with five choices that start with "None" and include risk analysis and risk management.
  • "Actions Taken in Response to Breach" is required, with 15 choices, among them a new or updated risk analysis, sanctioning staff, retraining, and free credit monitoring.
  • The brief description allows 4,000 characters.
  • The attestation warns that what you submit may be released under the Freedom of Information Act, and that for larger breaches some of it is posted on HHS's website.

The portal's front page says HHS investigates every breach affecting 500 or more people, and smaller ones "based on Departmental resources and enforcement priorities." Answer the safeguard and action questions so they match your risk analysis and your log.

Crashcart, which runs IT for small offices, keeps that log for practices under HIPAA. Each entry holds the incident, the four-factor risk assessment, your decision, and each notice with its due date, and every January and February it reminds you to report last year's smaller breaches to HHS. Deciding whether something is a breach, and signing the notices, stays with you and your attorney.

When you must notify the media

A breach involving "more than 500 residents of a State or jurisdiction" also requires notice to prominent media outlets serving that state, within the same 60 days and with the same content as the patient letter (164.406). HHS says practices usually do this with a press release.

The two thresholds differ. HHS's 60-day report starts at 500 people in total. Media notice starts above 500, counted per state. A practice near a state line with 400 affected patients in each of two states files with HHS within 60 days and notifies no media.

When the breach happens at a vendor

If a business associate such as your billing company, cloud EHR or IT provider has the breach, it must tell you within 60 days of its own discovery and identify each affected patient where it can (164.410). Your practice remains responsible for the patient notices, though HHS says you may delegate sending them to the vendor. Your business associate agreement should say who does what.

The encryption safe harbor

The notices apply only to unsecured information. HHS's guidance on unsecured PHI names two ways to secure it:

  • Encryption, with the key kept separate and not compromised. For stored data that means encryption consistent with NIST SP 800-111. For data in transit, NIST SP 800-52 (TLS), 800-77 (IPsec VPNs) or 800-113 (SSL VPNs), or other FIPS 140-2 validated methods.
  • Destruction. Paper and film shredded or destroyed so the information can't be reconstructed. HHS excludes redaction. Electronic media cleared, purged or destroyed consistent with NIST SP 800-88.

A stolen laptop with an encrypted drive and its key safe elsewhere is lost hardware, not a reportable breach. What to do when a work laptop is stolen walks through checking BitLocker or FileVault and the rest of that day's steps. The same goes for a copier or server you get rid of. Keep the record of how its drive was wiped, since that record shows the information was secured.

State laws come on top

State breach laws can require their own notices on top of HIPAA's. Data breach notification laws for small businesses explains how to find yours. Check the law of each state where affected patients live, and call your cyber insurer before any letter goes out.

Checklist for a HIPAA breach in a small practice

  1. Write down what happened, when it happened, and the day anyone on staff first knew.
  2. Stop it and preserve the evidence. Don't wipe affected computers.
  3. Check whether one of the three exceptions applies, and whether the data was encrypted or destroyed per HHS's guidance.
  4. Do the four-factor risk assessment in writing, with the conclusion and who made it.
  5. Count the people affected, by state.
  6. Call your cyber insurer and your attorney, and check state law.
  7. Mail patient letters with all five elements, within 60 days of discovery.
  8. 500 or more people: file with HHS within the same 60 days. Fewer: log it and file by 60 days after year end.
  9. More than 500 residents of one state: notify media there.
  10. Keep the assessment, letters, filings and confirmations for six years.

This is general information, not legal advice. For your situation, ask your attorney.

More in this topic

Crashcart runs IT and security for small offices for $35 a computer a month. Start a 14-day free trial.