Crashcart Start your free trial

Small office security

How to turn on MFA in Microsoft 365

Most small businesses should turn on Microsoft 365 MFA with security defaults, a free on and off switch in the Microsoft Entra admin center that makes every user register the Microsoft Authenticator app and blocks older sign-in methods that can't do MFA. Offices on Microsoft 365 Business Premium can use Conditional Access instead, which lets you choose who and what it covers. Per-user MFA is the fallback Microsoft no longer recommends. Before you switch anything on, create two emergency admin accounts, find the scanners and apps that send mail with only a password, and have staff register their phones, because security defaults no longer give users a 14-day grace period to do it.

MFA, multi-factor authentication, is the approval or code from your phone on top of the password. It's the first item in the cybersecurity checklist for small businesses, because a password typed into a fake sign-in page no longer opens the mailbox on its own.

Microsoft 365 is where most small offices in our own research keep their email. On October 14, 2026, we looked up the public mail records of 316 small tax and accounting firms in Alabama, Tennessee and Georgia, firms with 3 to 12 preparers and their own website, drawn from the IRS public list of preparers. Of the 262 domains that receive email, 117 deliver straight to Microsoft 365 and 39 more route through another service but name Microsoft 365 in their SPF record. That's 156 of 262, about 6 in 10.

Security defaults, per-user MFA or Conditional Access

Microsoft 365 offers three ways to require MFA, and you pick one. Microsoft's page on MFA in Microsoft 365 says security defaults and Conditional Access can't run together, and its per-user MFA page says not to mix per-user MFA with Conditional Access.

Security defaults Per-user MFA Conditional Access
Plans Every Microsoft 365 plan (Microsoft Entra ID Free) Every plan Plans with Microsoft Entra ID P1 or P2, such as Business Premium and Microsoft 365 E3
How it works One switch for the whole organization Turned on person by person Policies you write for users, apps and conditions
When users get asked Admins at every sign-in, everyone else "when necessary (for example, on new devices)" Every sign-in, with optional exceptions Whatever the policy says
Exceptions None Per person Any user or group, such as emergency accounts
Sign-in methods Microsoft Authenticator or another code app (OATH TOTP) What the user registers Set by the policy's authentication strength
Microsoft's view "A good, baseline level of sign-in security" "Not recommended" Its recommended approach

Microsoft's overview of Microsoft 365 for business security says every business plan includes Microsoft Entra ID Free with security defaults, and only Business Premium adds Entra ID P1 with Conditional Access. So the choice usually follows the plan you already pay for. On Business Basic or Standard, use security defaults. On Business Premium, use Conditional Access.

Per-user MFA has another catch. Microsoft's per-user MFA page says a user in the Enabled state can keep signing in to older apps with a password alone until they finish registering.

Number matching in Microsoft Authenticator

When someone signs in, the screen shows a number, and they type that number into the Authenticator notification on their phone. Microsoft's number matching page says it's on for all Authenticator push notifications, and its security defaults page says it helps stop "MFA fatigue" attacks, where an attacker with your password sends prompt after prompt until someone taps Approve.

Number matching only works if staff know what an unexpected prompt means. If a request arrives and you aren't signing in, someone else has your password. Deny it and tell whoever handles your IT that day, then follow what to do after clicking a phishing link.

CISA's Cybersecurity Performance Goals (goal 3.F) rank an authenticator app with number matching second, behind phishing-resistant methods such as passkeys, and ahead of text messages, which they say to use only when nothing else works.

How to roll out Microsoft 365 MFA without locking anyone out

1. Check what's on now

Sign in to the Microsoft Entra admin center and go to Entra ID, Overview, Properties, then Manage security defaults, per Microsoft's security defaults page. Organizations created after October 2019 started with them on, but someone may have turned them off. If any Conditional Access policy exists, even one switched off, Microsoft won't let you turn security defaults on.

2. Create two emergency access accounts

An emergency access account, often called a break-glass account, is a spare global administrator for the day nobody can sign in. Microsoft's emergency access guidance says to create two or more, as cloud-only accounts on your onmicrosoft.com domain, tied to no one person and to no employee's phone. It recommends a passkey on a physical security key, with the credentials stored somewhere safe and separate, and a sign-in test every quarter.

These accounts need MFA too. Microsoft began requiring MFA to sign in to the Microsoft 365 admin center in February 2025, rolling it out gradually, and its mandatory MFA page says that includes break-glass accounts. With Conditional Access, exclude these accounts from any policy that blocks sign-in.

3. Find what signs in with only a password

Security defaults block what Microsoft calls legacy authentication, meaning older programs and mail protocols such as IMAP, POP3 and SMTP that can't do MFA. Look for these before you switch:

  • Scanners and copiers that email scans. Many sign in to a mailbox with its username and password, which Microsoft calls client SMTP submission. Microsoft's guide for multifunction devices says that method isn't compatible with security defaults and is scheduled for deprecation. It lists other ways to send, such as SMTP relay through a connector, which needs a static IP address at the office.
  • Apps that send email for you, such as appointment reminders or invoices from practice or accounting software. Ask the vendor whether they support modern sign-in (OAuth) or another sending method.
  • Shared logins. If several people sign in to info@ or frontdesk@ with one password, MFA will tie that account to one person's phone. Make it a shared mailbox instead. Microsoft's shared mailbox page says to block sign-in for a shared mailbox's account and keep it blocked; people open it from their own accounts, with their own MFA.

How to run IT in a small office without an IT person covers the scanner settings in more detail.

4. Have everyone register first

Since July 29, 2024, security defaults no longer give users 14 days to register, so anyone who hasn't set up a method is asked to do it at their next sign-in. Have each person install Microsoft Authenticator, go to myprofile.microsoft.com, select Security info and add the app. A short staff meeting with everyone's phone out works better than an email.

CISA's small business guidance tells the owner to announce MFA personally and follow up with anyone who hasn't registered. If someone won't put a work app on a personal phone, security defaults offer no alternative to an authenticator app. Conditional Access can allow other methods, such as security keys.

5. Turn it on

For security defaults, go back to Entra ID, Overview, Properties, Manage security defaults, set it to Enabled and save. Microsoft says to then revoke existing sign-ins so everyone signs in again and registers. The Revoke sessions button on each user's Authentication methods page does it one person at a time.

For Conditional Access, Microsoft's policy to require MFA for all users goes under Entra ID, Conditional Access, Policies, New policy. Include All users, exclude your emergency access accounts, target All resources, and under Grant choose Require authentication strength with Multifactor authentication strength. Create it in Report-only mode first, check the results for a few days, then switch it On. Security defaults have to be off before the policy can be turned on.

6. Check who has it

On the free tier, open each person in the Entra admin center under Entra ID, Users, then Authentication methods, and confirm a method is listed. With Business Premium, Microsoft's authentication methods activity report at Entra ID, Authentication methods, Activity shows "Users capable of Azure multifactor authentication" on its Registration tab. Check again whenever someone joins or changes phones. If you use Crashcart, it checks who has MFA in Microsoft 365 once you connect it.

What to do when someone loses their phone

  1. Confirm it's them. Call the person at a number you already have before changing anything, since a request to reset someone's MFA is what an attacker holding their password would ask for.
  2. Clear the old phone. In the Entra admin center, go to Entra ID, Users, pick the person and open Authentication methods. Microsoft's page on managing methods says Require re-register MFA deletes their phone numbers, Authenticator apps and software code apps, and asks them to set up a new method at their next sign-in.
  3. If the phone was stolen, also choose Reset password and Revoke sessions, which forces every app to sign in again, including the mail app on the stolen phone.
  4. Register the new phone. The person signs in on a computer and adds Authenticator on the new phone when asked.

A Temporary Access Pass makes this easier. It's a passcode an admin creates, valid for one hour by default, that lets someone sign in and set up a new method; turn it on under Entra ID, Authentication methods, Policies. If the person with the lost phone is your only administrator, sign in with an emergency access account from step 2.

Microsoft 365 MFA checklist

  1. Check whether security defaults or any Conditional Access policy is on now.
  2. Create two emergency access accounts with passkeys, stored safely, and test them.
  3. List scanners, apps and shared logins that sign in with only a password, and move each to another method.
  4. Have every user register Microsoft Authenticator at myprofile.microsoft.com.
  5. Turn on security defaults, or a Conditional Access policy in Report-only mode, then On.
  6. Confirm every user has a method registered, and recheck monthly.
  7. Write down the lost-phone steps so whoever is covering IT can follow them.

More in this topic

Crashcart runs IT and security for small offices for $35 a computer a month. Start a 14-day free trial.