Microsoft 365 security settings for small businesses
The Microsoft 365 security settings a small business should check, in order, are MFA through security defaults or Conditional Access, legacy sign-in blocked, automatic forwarding to outside addresses turned off, the audit log recording, the Standard preset security policy, DKIM for your domain, few global admins with separate admin accounts, narrower SharePoint and OneDrive sharing, and Secure Score. Business Basic and Business Standard can do all of it except Conditional Access, the Defender for Office 365 parts of the preset policies and the full Secure Score, which come with Business Premium. The setting most offices miss is the audit log, which Microsoft says isn't turned on by default for Business Basic, Standard or Premium.
These are the settings behind the guide to email security for small businesses, which explains the attacks each one stops. Each step below gives the setting's name, where Microsoft's documentation puts it as of October 16, 2026, and the plan it needs. Microsoft moves menus often, so if a path has changed, search the admin center for the setting's name.
Microsoft 365 is the most common email service in our own research. On October 14, 2026, we checked the public mail (MX) and SPF records of 262 small tax and accounting firm domains in Alabama, Tennessee and Georgia that receive email, and 156 of 262 (about 6 in 10) use Microsoft 365.
Which Microsoft 365 security settings need Business Premium
| Setting | Business Basic and Standard | Business Premium |
|---|---|---|
| 1. MFA | Security defaults | Security defaults, or Conditional Access through Microsoft Entra ID P1 |
| 2. Block legacy authentication | Security defaults | Security defaults or a Conditional Access policy |
| 3. Automatic forwarding control | Yes | Yes |
| 4. Audit log and mailbox auditing | Yes, Audit (Standard) | Yes, Audit (Standard) |
| 5. Preset security policies | Exchange Online Protection settings | Adds Defender for Office 365 Plan 1: Safe Links, Safe Attachments, impersonation protection |
| 6. DKIM | Yes | Yes |
| 7. Admin roles | Yes | Yes |
| 8. SharePoint and OneDrive sharing | Yes | Yes |
| 9. Secure Score | Identity Secure Score in the Entra admin center | Secure Score in the Defender portal |
The plan details come from Microsoft's security overview for Microsoft 365 for business, its Purview service description and its Exposure Management licensing page. Defender for Office 365 is also sold as an add-on to the other plans.
1. Turn on MFA with security defaults or Conditional Access
MFA, multi-factor authentication, is the code or approval from your phone on top of the password. Microsoft 365 has two ways to require it for everyone, and they can't run together. Security defaults are one switch on every plan. Conditional Access lets Business Premium write policies with exceptions, such as for emergency admin accounts.
How to turn on MFA in Microsoft 365 covers choosing between them, the emergency accounts to create first and the rollout. Microsoft's security defaults page adds that security defaults also block device code flow, a sign-in method attackers abuse by getting someone to type a code on another device.
2. Block legacy authentication
Legacy authentication means older sign-in methods, such as IMAP, POP3 and SMTP with a plain password, that can't do MFA. Microsoft's Conditional Access guidance says more than 97 percent of credential stuffing attacks and more than 99 percent of password spray attacks use it.
Security defaults block it for you. On Business Premium with Conditional Access, add Microsoft's block policy in the Microsoft Entra admin center under Entra ID, Conditional Access, Policies, New policy: include All users, exclude your emergency access accounts, target All resources, set Conditions, Client apps to Exchange ActiveSync clients and Other clients only, and choose Block access. Start it in Report-only mode, then switch it to On.
Before either one, find out what still uses legacy sign-in. In the Entra admin center, open Entra ID, Monitoring & health, Sign-in logs, add the Client App column and filter for the legacy protocols, on the interactive and non-interactive tabs. The free tier keeps seven days of sign-ins and Business Premium keeps 30, so on Basic or Standard check twice, a few weeks apart.
Multifunction printers and scanners often send email with SMTP AUTH and a password. Microsoft's Exchange team announced that password-only SMTP AUTH will be turned off by default for existing tenants at the end of December 2026, with admins still able to turn it back on, and that a final removal date comes in the second half of 2027. The per-mailbox switch is Authenticated SMTP, under Users, Active users, the person, Mail, Manage email apps in the Microsoft 365 admin center, per Microsoft's SMTP AUTH page. Leave it checked only for a mailbox a device still needs, and move that device to another sending method.
3. Turn off automatic forwarding to outside addresses
An attacker who gets into a mailbox often adds a rule that forwards everything to an outside address, and keeps reading after the password changes. What to do about fake invoices sent from your email address shows where that leads.
The setting is Automatic forwarding rules in the outbound spam policy. Microsoft's forwarding page says the default, Automatic - System-controlled, behaves differently from one organization to another, and recommends choosing On or Off outright.
- See who forwards today. In the Exchange admin center, expand Reports, select Mail flow and open the Auto forwarded messages report, which lists each forwarder and the recipient's domain.
- In the Microsoft Defender portal at security.microsoft.com, go to Email & collaboration, Policies & rules, Threat policies, Anti-spam, and open Anti-spam outbound policy (Default).
- In its protection settings, under Forwarding rules, set Automatic forwarding rules to
Off - Forwarding is disabled, following Microsoft's steps. - If someone has a real reason to forward outside, create a custom outbound policy for that person set to On.
Off stops inbox rules and admin-set forwarding to outside addresses, bounces the message back to the sender, and leaves forwarding between your own staff alone.
4. Turn on the audit log and check mailbox auditing
The audit log records user and admin activity across Exchange, SharePoint, OneDrive and Microsoft Entra ID. After a mailbox is taken over, it's the record of what the attacker did. Microsoft's page on turning auditing on or off says auditing is on by default for Microsoft 365 organizations, then adds that it isn't for Business Basic, Business Standard and Business Premium, which have to turn it on by hand.
In the Microsoft Purview portal, open the Audit solution, or find it under View all solutions, Core, and select the banner Start recording user and admin activity. Microsoft says it can take up to 60 minutes to take effect. To confirm, run Get-AdminAuditLogConfig | Format-List UnifiedAuditLogIngestionEnabled in Exchange Online PowerShell. True means it's recording.
Mailbox auditing records actions inside each mailbox, such as a new inbox rule. Microsoft's mailbox auditing page says it's on by default in all organizations, and Get-OrganizationConfig | Format-List AuditDisabled returning False confirms it. Audit (Standard), included in every business plan, keeps records for 180 days. It only records from the day you turn it on, so do it before you need it.
5. Turn on the Standard preset security policy
Preset security policies apply Microsoft's recommended settings for spam, malware and phishing in one step. The preset security policy guide puts them in the Defender portal under Email & collaboration, Policies & rules, Threat policies, Preset Security Policies, and says Standard and Strict are likely off on your first visit.
- Turn on Standard protection and select Manage protection settings.
- On Apply Exchange Online Protection, choose All recipients.
- With Business Premium, choose the same recipients on Apply Defender for Office 365 protection, then add the people attackers would pretend to be, such as the owner and the bookkeeper, and the domains of firms you pay. Each preset takes up to 350 people and 50 extra domains, and covers your own domains automatically.
- Review and confirm.
Put whoever approves payments in Strict protection as well. Strict applies first when someone is in both, and the email security guide covers how the two differ.
If your MX record points to another filtering service in front of Microsoft 365, Microsoft's filters see that service's address instead of the real sender's. Microsoft's fix is Enhanced Filtering for Connectors on the inbound connector from that service. In our October 14 data, 39 of the 156 Microsoft 365 domains route mail through another service first.
6. Turn on DKIM for your domain
DKIM adds a signature to each message, which receiving servers check against a key published in your DNS. Microsoft's DKIM page says no signing happens for mail from your own domain until you set it up. The switch is Sign messages for this domain with DKIM signatures, on the DKIM tab of Email authentication settings in the Defender portal. How to set up DMARC for a small business has the steps.
On October 16, 2026, we looked up the DKIM records of those 156 Microsoft 365 domains at the two names Microsoft 365 uses, selector1._domainkey and selector2._domainkey, and followed each record to the key it points to. Cloudflare's and Google's public DNS gave the same results:
| What we found | Domains |
|---|---|
| No DKIM record at either name | 76 of 156 |
| Records that lead to a published key | 74 |
| Records that point to a key that isn't there | 6 |
The 6 are worth fixing first, since a receiving server that follows the record finds no key to check against. Domains behind another filtering service may sign under that service's own record names, which we didn't check. From outside we can see whether the records are in place, not whether signing is switched on.
7. Keep global admins few and use separate admin accounts
A Global Administrator can change almost every setting and reset anyone's password, so a phished global admin is the whole tenant. Microsoft's role best practices say to give the role to fewer than five people. Its admin account guidance for business plans adds:
- Use an ordinary account for email and daily work, and a separate account only for admin tasks. Admin-only accounts don't need a license.
- Name the admin account so it doesn't advertise what it is.
- Give the narrowest role that does the job. Creating accounts needs User Administrator, and resetting passwords needs Password Administrator or Helpdesk Administrator, per Microsoft's admin roles page.
To see who has what, go to Role assignments in the Microsoft 365 admin center, select Global Administrator and open the Assigned tab. Look for past staff, a former IT contractor or a vendor's support login. The two emergency access accounts from step 1 count toward the five. Passwords for admin accounts follow the office's password policy.
8. Narrow external sharing in SharePoint and OneDrive
Microsoft's email and collaboration guide for business plans says sharing starts at the most permissive level for SharePoint and OneDrive. In the SharePoint admin center, go to Policies, Sharing. The sharing settings page lists four levels: Anyone, New and existing guests, Existing guests, and Only people in your organization. OneDrive can be stricter than SharePoint, not looser.
Microsoft recommends the least permissive level, with Specific people as the default link type and View as the default permission under File and folder links. If your office sends clients files from OneDrive, New and existing guests is the workable middle, since outsiders have to sign in or enter a code sent to them. If you keep Anyone, make those links expire and limit them to View.
Guests usually lose access within an hour when you tighten the setting. Turning external sharing off and later back on gives guests their old access back, so turn sharing off on sensitive sites first.
9. Check Secure Score each month
Secure Score, at security.microsoft.com/securescore, lists Microsoft's recommended settings under Recommended actions, each worth 10 points or less. With security defaults on, Microsoft's Secure Score page awards full points for MFA for all users (9), MFA for admin roles (10) and blocking legacy authentication (7). Changes take 24 to 48 hours to show.
Microsoft's licensing page lists Business Premium among the plans with Secure Score in the Defender portal. On Basic or Standard, the free Identity Secure Score in the Entra admin center, under Entra ID, Identity Secure Score, covers the sign-in settings. Microsoft shows every recommendation for a product whatever your plan, so some won't apply to you, and it says the score isn't a measure of how likely a breach is. Read it as a to-do list.
Keeping the settings in place
Settings drift. Someone switches security defaults off to get a scanner working, a vendor gets a global admin role for one job and keeps it, a forwarding rule appears on one mailbox. Once a month, look at role assignments, the Auto forwarded messages report and Secure Score's history.
If you connect your Microsoft 365 to Crashcart, it reads accounts, admin roles, who has MFA, sign-in security settings and inbox rules that forward mail outside the business once a day. If you allow it, it also reads the activity log every 5 minutes for signs of a taken-over account, such as a new forwarding rule or a new sign-in method. It doesn't read anyone's mail or files, and changes to accounts wait for an owner's yes. Who gets admin rights and what the office shares outside stay your decisions.
Microsoft 365 security settings checklist
- MFA required for everyone, through security defaults or Conditional Access, with two emergency access accounts.
- Legacy authentication blocked, after checking the sign-in logs. Authenticated SMTP on only where a device still needs it.
- Automatic forwarding rules set to Off in the default outbound spam policy, with a custom policy for any exception.
- Audit log recording, with
UnifiedAuditLogIngestionEnabledshowing True, and mailbox auditing on. - Standard preset security policy on for all recipients, Strict for whoever approves payments, impersonation protection set up on Business Premium.
- DKIM signing on for every domain you send from, with its records leading to a published key.
- Fewer than five global admins, each a separate admin-only account, and narrower roles for everyone else.
- SharePoint and OneDrive sharing below Anyone, with Specific people and View as the link defaults.
- Secure Score or Identity Secure Score checked monthly.
More in this topic
Crashcart runs IT and security for small offices for $35 a computer a month. Start a 14-day free trial.