Crashcart Start your free trial

Cyber insurance and client security reviews

Common reasons cyber insurance claims are denied

A cyber insurance claim is usually denied, or paid only in part, for a reason written into the policy before the attack: the loss falls under a policy that isn't cyber insurance, notice reached the insurer late, money was spent without the insurer's consent, a sublimit capped the payment, an exclusion applied, or the application didn't match the office. In the court records we read, a ransomware claim under a business owner's policy was turned down the day it was filed, about $1.9 million in card-brand assessments fell to a contract exclusion, and an insurer paid $250,000 on a $3 million cyber policy under a ransomware sublimit until a federal judge rejected that reading. Most of these outcomes were settled by wording the policyholder could have read in advance. Read your policy and every endorsement now, and on the day of an incident, give written notice and get consent before you hire anyone or pay anything.

The guide to cyber insurance requirements for small businesses covers what insurers ask before they quote, and how a wrong answer on the application can void a policy. This post covers what decides the claim afterward.

The policy language we read

On October 16, 2026 we read two cyber policies in full with a PDF text extraction script. One is At-Bay's published Cyber Insurance Policy form, AB-CYB-001.2, edition 08/2023, 36 pages. The other is a real issued policy: the HSB Specialty Insurance policy filed as evidence in a Texas coverage lawsuit described below, built on the 2018 edition of the same At-Bay form. The other carriers we checked offered brochures, or full wording only to brokers, so these were the two we could read end to end.

What we counted What we found
Exclusions in At-Bay's 2023 form 28: 16 that apply to all coverage, 9 that apply to particular coverages, 3 for financial fraud coverage
Notice A "condition precedent" to coverage, in writing, "as soon as practicable," and no later than 90 days after the policy period ends
Where notice goes The address in Item 5 of the declarations, which in the issued policy was a claims email address
Places in At-Bay's 2023 form where spending needs the insurer's consent first 11
Endorsements in the issued policy 40 of its 86 pages, after the 36-page base form

The 11 consent requirements cover defense costs and settlements, any response firm not on the insurer's pre-approved list, forensic accountants for business interruption, reward payments, upgrades beyond what you had before the attack, and costs beyond what privacy law requires for notification, credit monitoring, legal services and regulatory audits. The endorsements in the issued policy included a ransomware sublimit and an exclusion tied to US sanctions. Both come up below.

The claim was filed under a policy that isn't cyber insurance

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners says on its cybersecurity page that "most commercial property and general liability policies do not cover cyber risks." A data breach add-on to a business owner's policy is not the same thing as a cyber policy.

The Ohio Supreme Court decided one of these in EMOI Services v. Owners Insurance Co., 2022-Ohio-4649. EMOI, a software company serving medical offices, paid a ransom of three bitcoins, about $35,000 at the time, after an attack in September 2019. Its insurer denied the claim the same day it was filed. The policy's data compromise endorsement excluded "any threat, extortion or blackmail," including ransom payments. Its electronic equipment endorsement paid only for "direct physical loss of or damage to" media. On December 27, 2022 the court held that encrypted software suffers no physical loss, and ruled for the insurer.

New York's Department of Financial Services told property and casualty insurers in its Circular Letter No. 2 (2021) to make clear "in any policy that could be subject to a cyber claim whether that policy provides or excludes coverage for cyber-related losses." If your business owner's policy has a data breach add-on, read its exclusions before counting on it for ransomware.

Notice reached the insurer late or in the wrong place

Both policies we read make written notice a "condition precedent," meaning the insurer owes nothing until it has been met. The clock starts when any member of the "Control Group" first becomes aware of a claim or discovers a cyber event. The form defines the Control Group by role, such as chief executive, chief financial officer and risk manager, "or any functionally equivalent positions, regardless of title." In a small office that usually includes the owner.

Three details in that condition catch people out:

  • It must be written and sent to the address in the declarations. A phone call to your agent is not the notice the form describes.
  • The coverage is claims-made. Liability coverage applies to claims first made during the policy period, and first-party coverage to events first discovered during it. Report anything you find before renewal, under the policy in force when you found it.
  • The outer limit is 90 days after the policy ends. "As soon as practicable" comes first, so don't wait for it. Ask your attorney how your state treats a notice that arrives late.

The policyholders in the court records gave notice fast. P.F. Chang's notified its insurer the same day it learned of its card breach in June 2014. CiCi Enterprises emailed the insurer's claims agent after its ransomware attack, and had a coverage letter 20 days after the attack. Neither case turned on notice.

The same policies require cooperation: help with the defense, and send the insurer copies of every demand, legal paper and invoice "as soon as practicable."

Money was spent before the insurer agreed

The 11 consent requirements in the form mean the order of your first calls matters. Hire a forensic firm your IT person recommends before the insurer agrees, and its bill may fall outside the policy. The form defines a covered response firm as one "on our pre-approved response provider list, available upon request from us," or another firm "only with our prior written consent."

The consent condition reads: "We shall not be liable for any settlement, Claim Expenses, assumed obligation, or admission to which we have not provided such consent." Admitting fault to a client or a vendor before talking to the insurer can cost you coverage too.

The CiCi record shows the sequence that works. According to the court, CiCi engaged a law firm and an incident response firm "with At-Bay's approval," and the response firm negotiated a $2,000,000 ransom demand down to $400,000.

Ask your broker for the pre-approved vendor list now and put it in your incident plan.

A sublimit capped the payment

A sublimit is a smaller limit inside the policy limit for one kind of loss. It is often in an endorsement, not the main form.

In CiCi Enterprises v. HSB Specialty Insurance Co., No. 3:23-CV-2155-L (N.D. Tex.), the insurer agreed the May 2022 ransomware attack was covered, then applied a Ransomware Event Sub-Limit Endorsement that capped "any single Ransomware Event" at $250,000. The policy limit was $3,000,000, and CiCi said its losses were over $1,200,000. On February 23, 2026 the court held that the sublimit, as written, did not reach the policy's cyber extortion coverage, and declared the full $3,000,000 limit available. Claims for breach of contract and under the Texas Insurance Code were left for trial.

CiCi had been in court for more than two years over one endorsement when that ruling came. The court's summary of the same policy also shows a $250,000 sublimit on certain financial fraud coverage, the part that pays for money sent on fraudulent instructions. Before you need the policy, list every sublimit next to the main limit.

An exclusion applied

Contracts. In P.F. Chang's China Bistro v. Federal Insurance Co., No. CV-15-01322 (D. Ariz.), the insurer had paid more than $1.7 million for forensics and lawsuits after a card breach. It refused $1,929,921.57 in Mastercard assessments that P.F. Chang's owed its card processor under their service agreement. On May 26, 2016 the court held the policy's exclusions for liability "assumed by any Insured under any contract or agreement" barred all of it. At-Bay's form has a similar contract exclusion, with a carve-out for card industry claims when that coverage is bought. If you take cards, check that your policy names PCI assessments. The guide to PCI compliance for small businesses explains where those assessments come from.

Something you knew about before. The form excludes anything a Control Group member knew of, before the continuity date in the declarations, that "reasonably would be regarded as" the basis for a claim. An incident you didn't mention on the application can fall here.

Outages at your providers. The form's infrastructure exclusion covers outages of electricity, gas, water and internet service. Its exceptions are for phone and network systems under your own direct control.

War. The form excludes loss "attributable to war, invasion, acts of foreign enemies, hostilities or warlike operations (whether war is declared or not)."

Sanctions. The issued HSB policy carried an OFAC exclusion endorsement for anything that violates US Treasury sanctions. Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control warned in its September 21, 2021 advisory that companies facilitating ransomware payments, naming cyber insurance firms, "may risk violating OFAC regulations," and that it can impose civil penalties "based on strict liability." It counts a prompt report to law enforcement or CISA as "a significant mitigating factor." New York's DFS letter says plainly that "DFS recommends against making ransom payments." A policy that covers extortion may still refuse to fund a payment to a sanctioned group.

The application didn't match the office

The application is part of the bargain. At-Bay's form says the insurer relied on it, and where the application has a misrepresentation made "with the actual intent to deceive," or one that "materially affect[s]" the insurer's acceptance of the risk, the policy gives no coverage for anything that flows from it, if a Control Group member knew. The same form says the insurer can't rescind the policy, so the rest of the coverage stays.

Other policies allow rescission. The guide to cyber insurance requirements covers the Travelers case in which the parties agreed to void a policy after the insurer said the applicant had overstated its multi-factor authentication. Check that answer against your settings before you sign. How to turn on MFA in Microsoft 365 shows how to confirm who has it, and common cyber insurance application questions goes through the rest of the form.

If your cyber insurance claim is denied

  1. Ask for the denial in writing, citing the policy provisions it relies on. The NAIC's Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act, a model law for states, lists "failing in the case of claims denials... to promptly provide a reasonable and accurate explanation of the basis" as an unfair claims practice.
  2. Read the cited provision in your own copy of the policy, endorsements included. In CiCi, the court read the endorsement's own words and found they didn't say what the insurer said they did.
  3. Appeal to the insurer first, then go to your state insurance department. The issued HSB policy opened with a Texas notice saying exactly that, and warning that if you don't also appeal through the insurer, "you may lose your right to appeal." The NAIC lists every state insurance department with its complaint page.
  4. Talk to an attorney before you accept a partial payment or sign a release.

Checklist to do before you need the policy

  1. Find the full policy: declarations, base form and every endorsement. Save it with the signed application.
  2. Write the notice address from the declarations and the insurer's breach hotline into your incident plan. If Crashcart runs your computers, the incident response plan it drafts for you to sign already includes your insurer's breach line.
  3. Get the insurer's pre-approved vendor list and add it to the plan.
  4. List the policy limit and every sublimit, including ransomware and funds transfer fraud.
  5. Read the exclusions for contracts, card assessments, prior knowledge, outages, war and sanctions.
  6. Check that each application answer is still true, starting with multi-factor authentication.
  7. On the day of an incident, give written notice to the declarations address, and hire no one and pay nothing without the insurer's written consent.
  8. Keep copies of every notice, approval, invoice and demand.

This is general information, not legal advice. For your situation, ask your attorney.

More in this topic

Crashcart runs IT and security for small offices for $35 a computer a month. Start a 14-day free trial.