Cyber insurance and client security reviews
Cyber insurance requirements for small businesses
Cyber insurance requirements for a small business are the security controls the carrier's application asks about before it will quote or renew: multi-factor authentication on email and remote access, backups kept apart from the network, endpoint detection and response, patching, staff training, an incident response plan and limits on admin accounts. Of eight carrier application forms we read in October 2026, seven ask about multi-factor authentication for remote access and six ask whether backups are offline or separate, but only two ask how often you test restoring them. Your answers become part of the policy, and in 2022 a federal court entered an agreed order rescinding a cyber policy after the insurer said the applicant had overstated its multi-factor authentication. Answer from evidence you can show.
There is no single standard list. Each carrier writes its own application, and the questions change between editions. This guide works from the forms themselves and covers what they ask, what each control means for an office of 3 to 30 people, what the policy pays for, what happens when an answer is wrong, and how to keep a record behind every answer.
What cyber insurance applications ask
On October 14, 2026 we downloaded the small business cyber applications and supplements we found posted on US carriers' own websites, and read each one in full with a PDF text extraction script. Eight forms from six carriers made the cut:
| Carrier | Form | Edition |
|---|---|---|
| At-Bay | Cyber Short Insurance Application, AB-CYB-SAP | 06/2026 |
| Tokio Marine HCC | NetGuard Plus New Business Application, NGP-NBA | 3/2026 |
| Corvus | Smart Cyber Insurance Application | Version 3.2, September 2024 |
| Travelers | CyberRisk Short Form Application, CYB-14103 | Ed. 01-19 |
| Travelers | Multi-Factor Authentication Supplement, CYB-14306 | Rev. 03-23 |
| The Hartford | CyberChoice Premier Application (Lower Revenue), CB 00 H027 02 0323 | 2023 |
| The Hartford | CyberChoice Supplemental Ransomware Application, 21-GS-1070800 | November 2021 |
| Admiral Insurance | Ransomware Supplemental Application, 182APP0323 | 03/2023 |
Five are main applications and three are supplements, the extra questionnaires a carrier sends with the main form. Travelers still posts its 2019 short form on its CyberRisk forms page, next to the 2023 MFA supplement. We left out forms written for other countries, copies hosted only by brokers, and a 2020 edition we couldn't confirm was still in use.
Here is how many of the eight ask about each control:
| Control | Forms that ask (of 8) | Which forms |
|---|---|---|
| Multi-factor authentication for remote access | 7 | All except Hartford CyberChoice Premier |
| Backups kept offline, separate or unchangeable | 6 | At-Bay, Tokio Marine HCC, Corvus, both Hartford forms, Admiral |
| Multi-factor authentication for email | 5 | At-Bay, Tokio Marine HCC, Corvus, both Travelers forms |
| Endpoint detection and response | 5 | At-Bay (optional question), Tokio Marine HCC, Corvus, Hartford supplement, Admiral |
| Multi-factor authentication for admin accounts | 4 | Tokio Marine HCC, Corvus, Travelers supplement, Admiral |
| How often patches are installed | 4 | Travelers short form, both Hartford forms, Admiral |
| Staff security training or phishing tests | 4 | Tokio Marine HCC, Corvus, Hartford supplement, Admiral |
| Encryption | 4 | Corvus, Travelers short form, Hartford CyberChoice Premier, Admiral |
| Vendors and outside IT providers | 4 | At-Bay (optional), Tokio Marine HCC, Travelers short form, Hartford supplement |
| A written incident response plan | 2 | Travelers short form, Admiral |
| How often backup restores are tested | 2 | Hartford supplement, Admiral |
| Verifying payment and bank change requests | 2 | Tokio Marine HCC, Corvus |
| Past incidents and claims | 5 of 5 main applications | Every main application |
Neither 2026 form asks how often you patch. The Hartford's 2023 lower-revenue application asks no multi-factor authentication question at all, though its ransomware supplement does. Many of the hard questions live in supplements, so expect one.
The post on common cyber insurance application questions walks through them group by group, with what each one tests and how to check your office before answering.
Multi-factor authentication on email and remote access
Multi-factor authentication, or MFA, means a sign-in needs something beyond the password, usually a code or a prompt on your phone. The forms ask about it more than anything else, split by what it protects.
Remote access. Seven of the eight forms ask whether MFA is required for remote access to your network. That means any way into the office systems from outside: a VPN, Remote Desktop, a remote support tool. Travelers' supplement and Tokio Marine HCC's application both extend the question to contractors and other third parties. Tokio Marine HCC names remote management tools too, which covers the tool your IT person uses to reach your computers.
Email. Five forms ask about MFA on email, in wording that differs. At-Bay asks about all email access. Tokio Marine HCC asks about MFA only if your staff can reach email through a web browser or a personal device, so anyone who opens email on their own phone brings the question into play. Corvus spells out webmail, the Outlook app and personal devices. If your office has one person without MFA, or an old mail program that skips it, "all" is not true.
The old mail program matters because, as Microsoft explains, legacy authentication doesn't support multifactor authentication. An attacker using an older protocol can get past an MFA policy unless legacy sign-ins are blocked, which Microsoft's security defaults do. The steps to turn MFA on and confirm who has it are in how to turn on MFA in Microsoft 365.
A promise for the whole year. A note above Tokio Marine HCC's 2026 MFA questions says a Yes means MFA is in place before the policy starts and stays in place for the whole policy period. On that form, Yes is a commitment about the next twelve months.
Backups kept separate from the network
Ransomware encrypts what it can reach, including a backup drive plugged into the server or a backup share any computer can write to. Six of the eight forms ask whether backups are kept offline, separated from the network or unchangeable, and their answer options show what they want to hear:
- At-Bay asks whether backups are offline or with a cloud provider, then which kind. Its list separates a dedicated cloud backup service from cloud sync such as OneDrive or Google Drive, which copies a deletion or an encrypted file everywhere.
- Corvus offers a checklist that includes immutable backups (copies that cannot be changed or deleted), a copy kept offline or air-gapped, backup servers segmented from the network and MFA to reach the backups.
- Tokio Marine HCC asks whether backups are immutable, kept separate from the network and protected by MFA, and how long a restore after a ransomware attack would take.
- The Hartford's application asks whether recent backups are routinely stored offline and isolated from threats to your production systems.
Only Admiral and The Hartford's ransomware supplement ask how often you test a restore. Test anyway, since a backup that has never been restored is a guess. How to protect backups from ransomware covers what makes a backup survive an attack.
In The Hartford's application, "Applicant" in the security questions includes any third party you rely on or trust with information. If an outside company holds your backups, your answer covers their setup too.
Endpoint detection and response
Five forms ask about endpoint detection and response, or EDR. Corvus's glossary describes EDR as security software that monitors each computer continuously, detects suspicious behavior and can block it automatically. The same glossary describes standard antivirus as scanning for and quarantining malicious files, and calls that minimal protection.
The forms ask more than whether you have it. Tokio Marine HCC asks whether EDR is on 100% of workstations and servers, and asks you to list any that are not covered. At-Bay asks who watches the alerts, with answers ranging from a 24/7 outside provider to deployed but not monitored. EDR that nobody reads at 2 a.m. is a weaker answer than the product name suggests.
The two oldest main forms, Travelers' 2019 short form and The Hartford's application, ask only about antivirus.
Patching and unsupported software
Four forms ask how often you install security updates. Admiral asks separately for servers and for desktops and laptops. The Hartford's application asks for a frequency, from immediately to not at all. The Hartford's supplement offers answers that include a patch management procedure, critical patches within 15 days of release and fully automated patching.
The same supplement asks how much of your network runs unsupported systems, meaning software that no longer gets security updates. For Windows 10, see Windows 10 end of support for small businesses.
Neither 2026 form asks about patching, and neither does Corvus. Two of those three look from the outside instead. Corvus's form says it scans the applicant's website and affiliated sites, and Tokio Marine HCC's signature section gives consent to non-intrusive scans of internet-facing systems, so an unpatched firewall or VPN can show up without a question being asked.
Security training and phishing tests
Four forms ask about staff training. Corvus and Admiral ask whether training happens at least once a year. Tokio Marine HCC asks whether all employees complete social engineering training that includes phishing simulations, which are fake phishing emails sent to see who clicks. Admiral lists the topics it expects, including incident reporting procedures, passwords and email use, and asks separately about annual phishing tests.
A training answer needs a record of who took it, when, and what it covered. The small business cybersecurity checklist puts training alongside the other basics, and what to do after clicking a phishing link covers the response when training doesn't stop someone.
An incident response plan
Only two of the eight forms ask directly for an incident response plan, a written list of what to do and who to call when something goes wrong. Travelers' short form asks for a plan to respond to a network intrusion, plus a disaster recovery or business continuity plan. Admiral asks for an incident response plan that includes business continuity steps for a ransomware attack. Corvus asks for a business continuity or disaster recovery plan and whether it was tested in the last 12 months.
Write one even if your form doesn't ask. The first call after an attack goes to the insurer's breach hotline, and the plan is where that number lives. For a small office it can be two pages covering who to call first, not to wipe or switch off affected computers, how to keep working on paper, and where the backups are.
Admin accounts and privileged access
Admin accounts can install software, change settings and turn off security tools, and so can an attacker who gets one. Four forms ask whether admin accounts require MFA. Travelers' supplement asks about all admin access, internal and remote, to directory services, backup systems, network equipment such as firewalls, and the computers and servers themselves.
Two forms also ask how admin rights are handed out. Admiral asks whether workstations are barred from local admin rights and how many people hold permanent admin access. Corvus asks whether standard users lack admin rights on their own computers and whether admins use separate accounts for daily work. If everyone in your office is an admin on their own PC, the honest answer is No. Removing those rights is a settings change on each computer, and it changes the answer.
Admiral also asks whether accounts are shut off immediately when someone leaves. The employee offboarding IT checklist covers that step.
Vendors, outside IT and payment requests
Four forms ask about outside companies. Tokio Marine HCC asks for your three most critical vendors and their websites. The Hartford's supplement asks how access by a managed service provider (an outside IT company) is controlled, with answers such as MFA for their access or a security assessment. Travelers' short form asks whether vendors with access to your systems must show adequate security. Tokio Marine HCC also has a section the person responsible for network security must complete, with the provider's name if that job is outsourced. When a client sends you its own form, see how to answer a vendor security questionnaire.
Corvus and Tokio Marine HCC also ask whether you confirm a request to send money or change bank details by calling the requester at a number you already had. That question is about fake payment requests sent by email, and email security for small businesses covers the email side.
What a cyber insurance policy covers
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners says on its cybersecurity page that most commercial property and general liability policies do not cover cyber risks, and that cyber policies are highly customized. Don't assume your business owner's policy pays for a ransomware attack, or that two cyber policies cover the same things.
The Federal Trade Commission's cyber insurance guide for small businesses, developed with the NAIC, splits coverage in two:
| Type | What it protects | Costs it typically includes |
|---|---|---|
| First-party coverage | Your own data and business, including employee and customer information | Legal advice on notification duties, data recovery, customer notices and a call center, lost income from business interruption, crisis management, cyber extortion and fraud, forensics, and fees, fines and penalties tied to the incident |
| Third-party coverage | Your liability when someone else brings a claim against you | Payments to affected consumers, claim and settlement costs, defamation and copyright or trademark claims, litigation and regulatory inquiries, judgments, accounting costs |
The FTC suggests checking that a policy covers breaches, attacks on your data held by vendors, attacks anywhere in the world and terrorist acts, and asking whether the insurer has a duty to defend you and a breach hotline open at all hours.
Two terms from the forms matter before you buy. Four of the five main applications we read say on their first page that the liability parts are claims-made, which means they cover claims first made against you during the policy period. Let the policy lapse and a claim that arrives next month may have nowhere to go. The same four forms say that defense costs reduce the limit, so legal fees come out of the same pot as settlements.
How a wrong answer can matter at claim time
The application is not a survey. The Hartford's says it becomes the basis of the contract and part of the policy. Tokio Marine HCC's says it forms part of the policy if coverage is bound. At-Bay's says "any misrepresentation, omission, concealment or otherwise shall be grounds for the rescission" of the policy. Rescission means the policy is treated as if it never existed, so nothing is paid under it.
That has happened over multi-factor authentication. In July 2022 Travelers sued its policyholder International Control Services in federal court in Illinois. According to Travelers' complaint, the company's application answered Yes to requiring MFA for administrative or privileged access, and its signed MFA attestation said MFA covered email, remote access and admin access to servers, backups and network equipment. Those are the same questions as on Travelers' current MFA supplement. After a ransomware attack in May 2022, Travelers said it learned that MFA protected only the firewall. The parties agreed to rescind the policy, and on August 30, 2022 the court entered an order declaring it void from its inception, with no coverage for any claim. Both filings are on the court docket. The court made no finding on who was right; the order rests on the parties' agreement.
State law decides when a wrong answer can void a policy. Illinois, where that case was filed, says in section 154 of its Insurance Code that a misrepresentation voids a policy only if it was made with actual intent to deceive or materially affects the insurer's acceptance of the risk. A carrier that says it wouldn't have issued the policy without MFA is arguing the second. Other states have their own rules, which is a question for your attorney.
A wrong answer is one of several reasons a claim can fail; common reasons cyber insurance claims are denied covers the others. Three habits keep you clear of this one:
- Answer for every person and every system. One user without MFA makes "all users" false.
- Use the space for No answers. Travelers, Tokio Marine HCC and Admiral all give room to explain a No or describe what you do instead. An explained No is information the underwriter can price. A wrong Yes is a defense the insurer can raise later.
- Report changes. Travelers, The Hartford, Tokio Marine HCC and At-Bay all say you must tell them about changes to your answers, and the last three name the time before the policy takes effect. If you turn MFA off for a week while switching email providers, that's a change.
The Hartford requires the CEO, CFO, owner, controller, president or board chair to sign. Travelers' MFA supplement asks whether the signer had help from the person in charge of IT security. The owner signs, but the person who knows the answers should check them first.
How to keep evidence for each answer
What protects you in a dispute is a dated record, made when you answered, showing the control was in place. Save it with the signed application and every supplement, since At-Bay's and The Hartford's forms both fold supplements and other written materials into the application.
| Requirement | Evidence to keep | Where it comes from | With Crashcart |
|---|---|---|---|
| MFA on email and remote access | A dated export showing every user is MFA-capable, and the setting that enforces it | Microsoft Entra admin center, Entra ID, Authentication methods, Activity (needs an Entra ID P1 or P2 license), or the Google Admin console's Security user report (2-Step Verification enrollment column); your VPN or remote tool's admin report | Checks who has two-step sign-in in Microsoft 365, once you connect it |
| Backups kept separate | Where copies are stored, who can delete them, and the date and result of the last test restore | Your backup service's console and restore log | Backs up nightly to storage computers can't delete, runs a test restore weekly and logs both |
| EDR on every computer | A list of computers with EDR installed and who watches alerts | Your EDR console, compared with a count of the office's computers | A security team watches every computer, 24/7 |
| Patching | Update status for each computer on a date | Windows Update history, or your management tool's report | Installs updates automatically and logs each check and fix by date |
| Training | Who completed it, when and what it covered | Your training provider's completion report, or a signed sign-in sheet | Emails a monthly security tip and keeps the record of who's had training |
| Incident response plan | The signed plan with its date and the insurer's breach hotline in it | Your own document | Drafts the plan, insurer's breach line included, for you to sign |
| Admin accounts | A list of who has admin rights on each computer and in email | Each computer's local administrators group; the email admin console's role list | Checks admin rights on every computer each morning |
| Vendors | A list of outside companies with access to your data or systems, and what each agreed to | Your contracts and vendor list | Keeps the vendor list and where each agreement stands |
| Encryption | Encryption status for each laptop and desktop | BitLocker or FileVault status on each computer | Checks disk encryption each morning |
Crashcart is our product. The last column shows what its evidence log records, every check and fix by date. The other columns work without it.
At renewal, pull fresh copies and compare them with last year's answers before you sign.
Checklist before you sign the application
- Ask your broker for the full application and every supplement well before the renewal date.
- Read each question for its scope (all users, all remote access, all computers) and have the person who runs your IT check every technical answer.
- Confirm MFA for every email account, every remote access path and every admin account, and block legacy sign-ins.
- Confirm at least one backup copy is offline or cannot be deleted from the office computers, and run a test restore.
- List every computer and confirm EDR or antivirus is on each one and updates are current.
- Record who completed security training this year.
- Write or update the incident response plan with the insurer's breach hotline.
- List who has admin rights and remove the ones nobody needs.
- List your vendors and outside IT providers and how they connect.
- Answer No where No is true, and explain it in the space provided.
- Save the signed application, the supplements and the dated evidence together.
- Tell the carrier in writing if any answer changes before the policy starts.
This is general information, not legal advice. For your situation, ask your attorney.
More in this topic
Crashcart runs IT and security for small offices for $35 a computer a month. Start a 14-day free trial.