Crashcart Start your free trial

Law firm data security

The lawyer technology competence rule for small firms

The lawyer technology competence rule is Comment 8 to ABA Model Rule 1.1, added in 2012, which says that staying competent includes keeping abreast of "the benefits and risks associated with relevant technology." The ABA's own chart, last updated April 4, 2023, counts 39 jurisdictions that have adopted a statement on technology competence, and lists Alabama and Georgia among those that haven't. For a small firm, competence doesn't mean running your own IT. It means knowing enough about your systems to make reasonable decisions about them, and supervising the people and companies who run them, which Rule 5.3 already requires.

The Model Rules are a model, and each state adopts its own. Your state's rule and its bar's ethics opinions control, so read them before relying on anything here. Our guide to cybersecurity for small law firms covers the other ethics rules that apply to client data.

What the lawyer technology competence rule says

Model Rule 1.1 says "A lawyer shall provide competent representation to a client." The technology language sits in the commentary, under the heading Maintaining Competence. Comment 8 reads in full:

To maintain the requisite knowledge and skill, a lawyer should keep abreast of changes in the law and its practice, including the benefits and risks associated with relevant technology, engage in continuing study and education and comply with all continuing legal education requirements to which the lawyer is subject.

The ABA added the technology language in 2012, on the recommendation of its Commission on Ethics 20/20.

Did Comment 8 create a new duty?

The ABA says no. Formal Opinion 477R describes the 2012 change as a clarification, made "when the ABA recognized the increasing impact of technology on the practice of law and the duty of lawyers to develop an understanding of that technology." It quotes the Ethics 20/20 Commission as concluding that "lawyers necessarily need to understand basic features of relevant technology," and that the amendment "does not impose any new obligations on lawyers."

That cuts both ways. If the comment added no new obligation, a lawyer in a state without it shouldn't assume technology falls outside competence. A lawyer in a state with it hasn't picked up a separate checklist. The duty is the same competence duty, applied to the tools the lawyer uses.

The same opinion says how a lawyer who isn't technical meets it: "Any lack of individual competence by a lawyer to evaluate and employ safeguards to protect client confidences may be addressed through association with another lawyer or expert, or by education."

How many states have adopted the technology competence rule

The ABA Center for Professional Responsibility keeps a chart on Rule 1.1, Comment 8 and technological competence. On the version last updated April 4, 2023, it says "Thirty-nine (39) jurisdictions have adopted a statement on tech competence," and names them.

It also lists the jurisdictions without one:

  • With comments to their rules but no technology statement: Alabama, the District of Columbia, Georgia, Maine, Maryland, Mississippi and Rhode Island.
  • Without formal comments at all: Louisiana, Nevada, New Jersey, Oregon and South Dakota. The chart notes a Louisiana State Bar Association opinion on the subject.

Adoption isn't uniform. The chart shows North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Carolina and Virginia with the statement in a differently numbered comment, and Montana, which has no official comments, with it in its Preamble. The chart is more than three years old, so a state may have acted since. Check your state's current rules rather than any count, including this one.

How Alabama, Tennessee and Georgia word the rule

To see how far state versions drift from the model, we picked three neighboring states. On October 18, 2026 we read Rules 1.1, 1.6 and 5.3 and their comments on each state's official site: the Tennessee Supreme Court's Rule 8, the State Bar of Georgia's Rule 1.1, Rule 1.6 and Rule 5.3, and the Alabama court system's PDFs of Rule 1.1, Rule 1.6 and Rule 5.3. We compared each with the Model Rules on three points.

ABA Model Rules Tennessee Georgia Alabama
Technology in the competence comment Comment [8] Comment [8], the same words No. Comment [6] says only to "engage in continuing study and education" No. The comment says only to "engage in continuing study and education"
Reasonable efforts to protect client information Rule 1.6(c) Rule 1.6(d), same wording Comment [24] to Rule 1.6, worded "should" Not in Rule 1.6 or its comments
Outside services in the Rule 5.3 comments Comment [3] names "an Internet-based service to store client information" Comment [3], same example Comment [4] covers nonlawyers outside the firm, with no examples The comment covers the lawyer's own assistants only

Three things stood out.

Tennessee matches the Model Rules almost word for word. Its Comment [8] differs from the ABA's by one comma, after "education." Its reasonable-efforts paragraph is lettered (d) instead of (c), so a Tennessee lawyer citing "Rule 1.6(c)" is citing a different paragraph.

Georgia has the security duty but not the technology comment. Comment [24] to Georgia's Rule 1.6 says a lawyer "should make reasonable efforts to prevent the inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure of, or unauthorized access to" client information, with the same five factors as Comment 18 to the Model Rule. Its competence comment stops at continuing study and education.

Alabama has neither. Alabama's Rule 1.1 shows an amendment effective March 26, 2012, months before the ABA's technology change, and its comment on maintaining competence doesn't mention technology. Its Rule 1.6 has no paragraph on reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized access. That doesn't mean an Alabama lawyer has no duty to protect client files. It means the duty isn't spelled out in those rules. Check the Alabama State Bar's ethics opinions, and ask your own counsel how Alabama's confidentiality rule applies to electronic files.

What Rule 5.3 says about your IT provider and cloud vendors

Rule 5.3 covers nonlawyers "employed or retained by or associated with a lawyer." Partners and lawyers with comparable managerial authority must make reasonable efforts to ensure the firm has measures giving reasonable assurance that the person's conduct "is compatible with the professional obligations of the lawyer." A lawyer with direct supervisory authority has the same duty for that person.

Comment [3] brings in outside services, including "using an Internet-based service to store client information." How much the lawyer has to do depends on:

  • the education, experience and reputation of the nonlawyer
  • the nature of the services
  • the terms of any arrangements concerning the protection of client information
  • the legal and ethical environments where the services are performed, especially on confidentiality

It adds that the lawyer "should communicate directions appropriate under the circumstances." For a small firm, that covers the IT company or relative who looks after the computers, your email and cloud storage provider, the practice management system and any AI tool staff use. Our post on who should handle IT for a small office compares the options and lists the accounts the firm should keep in its own name, whoever you choose.

This is where competence and supervision meet. You can't give a vendor appropriate directions, or judge its work, without knowing what it does for you.

What technology competence means for a small firm

Comment 8 doesn't list skills. The Ethics 20/20 Commission considered more detailed guidance on security measures and decided against it, concluding, as Opinion 477R quotes it, that "technology is changing too rapidly to offer such guidance." In practice, a partner at a small firm should be able to answer these without calling anyone:

  • Where does client information live: which systems, devices and vendors?
  • Who holds the admin passwords for email, the domain and the practice management system, and are those accounts in the firm's name?
  • Is multi-factor authentication on for every account that reaches client data?
  • When was a backup last restored as a test, and how long did it take?
  • Which computers no longer get security updates?
  • Which vendors hold client data, and what do their terms say about security and breach notice?
  • Which tools do staff use for client work, including AI tools, and what does the firm allow?
  • Who do you call first if a computer is locked by ransomware, and is it written down?

A partner who can answer these is in a position to make the decisions Rule 1.6 calls for and to supervise under Rule 5.3. For the settings behind several of them, our checklist for ABA Formal Opinion 477R goes through email, file sharing and vendors in Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace.

Keeping your technology knowledge current

Comment 8 ties technology to continuing study, so competence has a date on it. A setup you understood three years ago may have changed under you: a new laptop, a new vendor, a setting Microsoft or Google moved. Set a yearly review of the questions above, and keep notes on what you found and decided.

The harder part is getting plain answers in between. Crashcart explains each problem it finds, and its fix, in plain language, and a report at the start of each month shows what changed. That gives a partner something concrete to read and question. Deciding what is reasonable for the firm, and what clients are told, stays with the lawyers.

This is general information, not legal advice. For your situation, ask your attorney.

More in this topic

Crashcart runs IT and security for small offices for $35 a computer a month. Start a 14-day free trial.