ABA Formal Opinion 483 for small law firms
ABA Formal Opinion 483, issued October 17, 2018, sets out a lawyer's ethics duties around a data breach. Before one, a lawyer must make reasonable efforts to monitor the firm's technology and vendors, and should consider writing an incident response plan. During one, the lawyer must act promptly to stop it and make reasonable efforts to restore systems. Afterwards, the lawyer must find out what was accessed and tell current clients when material client information was, or is substantially likely to have been, involved, on top of whatever state breach notice laws require.
The opinion, "Lawyers' Obligations After an Electronic Data Breach or Cyberattack," runs 16 pages and is on the ABA's website. It rests on Model Rules 1.1, 1.4, 1.6, 5.1 and 5.3, which our guide to cybersecurity for small law firms covers along with the safeguards that meet them.
Two caveats. The opinion is advisory: its first footnote says the rules and opinions of individual jurisdictions are controlling, so check what your state's rules and state bar say. And it says how a lawyer complies depends on the firm's size and structure and the lawyer's position in it.
What counts as a data breach under Opinion 483
Not every incident. The opinion defines a data breach as an event where material client confidential information is misappropriated, destroyed or otherwise compromised, or where the lawyer's ability to do the legal work they were hired for is significantly impaired.
It describes three kinds:
- theft of client confidential information
- ransomware that locks client information until a ransom is paid, even when nothing is accessed or taken
- an attack that destroys the systems the lawyer works on
Many cyber events happen in law offices every day without being a breach, because no material client information is compromised. For a small firm the second item matters most. Ransomware that shuts the office down for a week can fall within the definition even if nobody copied a file.
Before a breach
Monitoring is required
Reading the opinion closely, we found the monitoring duty names three things to monitor, not one. Lawyers must use "reasonable efforts to monitor the technology and office resources connected to the internet," the external data sources they rely on, and the external vendors that provide services relating to data. The vendor part is easy to miss. Your cloud storage, practice management software, email provider and IT provider all fall within it.
The opinion grounds the duty in competence and in Rules 5.1 and 5.3 on supervision. Without monitoring, it says, a lawyer's recognition of a breach could be "relegated to happenstance."
The standard is reasonable effort, not perfect detection. Missing a well-hidden intrusion is not necessarily a violation. The risk arises when a lack of reasonable effort caused the breach.
For a small firm, reasonable monitoring might mean endpoint protection on every computer with alerts someone acts on, sign-in alerts on the email system, and one named person who receives every vendor's security and breach notices.
An incident response plan is recommended
The opinion stops short of requiring a plan. It says lawyers "should consider proactively developing an incident response plan," and that the decision, the plan's content and any training for it should happen before a breach, not during one.
It quotes a description of what such plans share. The process should promptly identify and evaluate a possible intrusion, assess its nature and scope, determine whether data was accessed, quarantine the threat, prevent information leaving the firm, remove the malware and restore the network. The plan should name the team members and their backups, give a way to reach them at any time, define each person's role and steps, and name the one person in overall charge.
In a five-person firm the team is short: the managing partner, the office manager, whoever handles IT, a breach lawyer and the cyber insurer. Write down their phone numbers and the insurer's breach hotline, and print the plan. A copy stored only on the encrypted server won't help.
During a breach
Stop it
When a breach is suspected or detected, the opinion says Rule 1.1 requires the lawyer to act reasonably and promptly to stop it and limit the damage. It leaves how to the circumstances. If the breach started with one email account, our guide on what to do after clicking a phishing link gives the first steps in order: change the password from another device, sign the account out everywhere, and remove forwarding rules the attacker added.
Restore operations
Once the breach is stopped, a competent lawyer must make all reasonable efforts to restore computer operations so clients can be served again, either alone if qualified or with experts. The opinion treats restoration as a chance to fix what let the attacker in, whether by restoring the old systems, moving to new ones, or doing a task without technology. A footnote adds that some information may be too sensitive to keep electronically at all.
Restoring depends on having a backup the attack couldn't reach. Our post on protecting backups from ransomware covers how to check yours before you need it.
Telling law enforcement
The opinion treats reporting the breach to police or the FBI as a disclosure that Rule 1.6 may impliedly authorize. Before making it, the lawyer must consider whether the client would object, whether the client would be harmed, and whether reporting would help end the breach or recover the information. Without the client's consent, share only what is reasonably necessary for those purposes.
After a breach
Find out what happened
A lawyer would check which paper files were stolen in a burglary, and the opinion says the same reasonable attempts are required to find out whether electronic files were accessed and which ones. The investigation has to gather enough to be sure the intrusion has stopped, then evaluate what was lost or accessed. That information is what makes an accurate notice to clients possible, under the duty to communicate in Rule 1.4 and the duty of honesty in Rule 8.4(c).
So don't wipe or rebuild the affected computers before someone has looked at them. Their logs can show which files were reached.
Tell current clients
When a lawyer knows or reasonably should know a breach has occurred, the lawyer must evaluate notice. The duty to notify current clients comes from Rule 1.4, which requires keeping clients reasonably informed. It applies when a breach involves, or has a substantial likelihood of involving, material client confidential information.
We found two details in this section that change how a firm should prepare.
First, there is no safe harbor for notice. Under Comment 18 to Rule 1.6, a lawyer who made reasonable security efforts hasn't violated Rule 1.6(c) even if data is lost. Opinion 483 says that protection doesn't carry over: once notice is triggered, the lawyer must notify "irrespective of what type of security efforts were implemented." Good security can keep you out of trouble under Rule 1.6. It does not spare you the letter to clients.
Second, the opinion sets a minimum for what the notice says. Every affected client must be told:
- that there has been unauthorized access to or disclosure of their information, or that it is reasonably suspected
- the known or reasonably ascertainable extent of what was accessed or disclosed
- if the lawyer made reasonable efforts but couldn't determine the extent, that fact
As a best practice, the notice should also say what the firm is doing about it, from trying to recover information to improving security. The opinion adds a continuing duty to keep clients "reasonably apprised of material developments" in the investigation.
The opinion's own example: no notice is required if ransomware hit the file server but no client information was inaccessible for a material amount of time, and none was accessed or disclosed.
Former clients
The committee declined to require notice to former clients as a matter of ethics, because no rule says so. It warns that data privacy laws, common law duties of care or contracts with the former client may require notice anyway. As a best practice, it suggests agreeing with clients, before or at the end of the representation, on what happens to their electronic files, and otherwise following a document retention schedule.
State breach notice laws are separate
The opinion notes that all 50 states, the District of Columbia, Guam, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands have breach notification statutes. They protect individuals whose personal information was exposed, whether or not they are clients.
The two sets of duties run side by side. The opinion says complying with state breach laws, HIPAA or the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act "does not necessarily achieve compliance with ethics obligations," and that complying with the ethics rules doesn't satisfy those laws either. Analyze each separately, with breach counsel if you can.
Keep less client data
Some of the most practical advice in Opinion 483 is in a footnote. Because statutory notice duties are broad, it suggests lawyers manage how much confidential and personally identifiable information they keep, follow a retention policy consistent with Rule 1.15, and limit what they receive and hold during and after an engagement. A closed file you no longer keep can't be part of a breach. Set a retention schedule, close out files on it, and clear old client documents out of email and download folders.
This is general information, not legal advice. For your situation, ask your attorney.
More in this topic
Crashcart runs IT and security for small offices for $35 a computer a month. Start a 14-day free trial.