ABA Formal Opinion 477R checklist for small law firms
ABA Formal Opinion 477R says a lawyer may send client information by ordinary email and store it online, as long as the lawyer has made reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized access. For a small firm on Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, that comes down to seven tasks: decide which matters need more than ordinary email, list where client information is stored, turn on the basic safeguards, encrypt sensitive documents or send them through a portal, label confidential messages, train staff, and check your vendors. Most of it is settings you already pay for. Encrypted email is the exception, because the cheaper business plans don't include it.
Formal Opinion 477R was issued on May 11, 2017 and revised on May 22, 2017. It replaced the ABA's 1999 opinion on email and is on the ABA's website. It is advisory. Its first footnote says the rules and opinions "promulgated in individual jurisdictions are controlling," so check your state's version of Rule 1.6 and your state bar's opinions. Our guide to cybersecurity for small law firms covers the rules behind it, and what to do after a breach is in our post on ABA Formal Opinion 483.
What ABA Formal Opinion 477R asks of a small firm
The opinion's conclusion is one sentence: "A lawyer generally may transmit information relating to the representation of a client over the internet without violating the Model Rules of Professional Conduct where the lawyer has undertaken reasonable efforts to prevent inadvertent or unauthorized access."
It doesn't list required products. It calls for "a 'process' to assess risks, identify and implement appropriate security measures responsive to those risks, verify that they are effectively implemented, and ensure that they are continually updated in response to new developments." Ordinary email is still fine for routine matters. The opinion says "the use of unencrypted routine email generally remains an acceptable method of lawyer-client communication," presuming basic security is in place.
The opinion gives seven considerations as guidance. The steps below follow them in order.
Which client matters need more than ordinary email
Consideration 1 says matters involving trade secrets, industrial designs, or mergers and acquisitions, and clients in healthcare, banking, defense or education, "may present a higher risk of data theft," and that "greater effort is warranted" for them.
The client's own email matters as much as the subject. The opinion says the lawyer should warn a client about using "a computer or other device, or email account, to which a third party has, or may gain, access." A footnote cites a 2015 Texas ethics opinion whose examples include a spouse in a divorce who may know the client's password, and a client writing from a work account about a dispute with that employer.
Raise it at intake. Consideration 4 says "the lawyer and client should discuss what levels of security will be necessary for each electronic communication about client matters" at the start of the relationship, and the section on Rule 1.4 says that for highly sensitive information they "should decide whether another mode of transmission, such as high level encryption or personal delivery is warranted." Add a line to your engagement letter asking which email address the client wants used, and note which matters get encrypted email or the portal.
How to list where client email and files are stored
Consideration 2 asks you to understand where client data resides and how it can be reached. "Every access point is a potential entry point for a data loss or disclosure," it says. "Each access point, and each device, should be evaluated for security compliance."
On Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace the list usually covers each mailbox and shared mailbox, OneDrive and SharePoint (including the sites behind Teams) or Google Drive and shared drives, the practice management system and its portal, phones with the Outlook or Gmail app, home computers that open firm email, the copier that emails scans, e-signature and billing accounts, and backups. Write down who can reach each one. Every later step uses this list.
How to turn on the basic safeguards
Consideration 3 names secure Wi-Fi or a VPN, unique passwords, firewalls, anti-malware software on every device that holds client information, and security updates. "Each of these measures is routinely accessible and reasonably affordable or free," it says, and firms "may consider refusing access to firm systems to devices failing to comply with these basic methods."
It lists disk encryption and multi-factor authentication only as "other available tools." Treat them as basics anyway. Multi-factor authentication (MFA) means a code or approval from your phone on top of the password, and neither suite charges extra for it:
- Microsoft 365. Security defaults need no extra license. In the Microsoft Entra admin center, go to Entra ID, Overview, Properties, Manage security defaults. Our guide to turning on MFA in Microsoft 365 covers the rollout.
- Google Workspace. In the Admin console, go to Security, Authentication, 2-step verification, allow it, then set Enforcement.
The opinion's "unique complex passwords, changed periodically" is out of date. Federal guidance, NIST SP 800-63B-4, says systems shall not require periodic password changes, only a change when there is evidence of compromise.
How to send encrypted email from Microsoft 365 or Gmail
Consideration 4 says "if client information is of sufficient sensitivity, a lawyer should encrypt the transmission and determine how to do so to sufficiently protect it," and consider password protection for attachments. Here your plan decides your options.
Microsoft 365. Microsoft Purview Message Encryption is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium. Business Basic and Business Standard need Azure Information Protection Plan 1 added, for each user who uses it. Staff encrypt from Outlook with the encrypt-only or Do Not Forward option, and a recipient outside Microsoft 365 reads the message in a web browser with nothing to download. The limit is 25 MB including attachments, and OneDrive or SharePoint links in the message aren't encrypted. An admin can also add a mail flow rule that encrypts automatically, for example any message with "privileged" in the subject.
Google Workspace. Gmail's hosted S/MIME encryption is listed only for Frontline Plus, Enterprise Plus and the Education editions, and users must exchange keys with each recipient first. Gmail's confidential mode sets an expiration date, lets you revoke access and blocks forwarding and downloading, but Google's help page warns that recipients "can still take screenshots or photos of your emails." On a Business edition, use a portal or an encrypted file.
Password-protected files. In Word for Windows, go to File, Info, Protect Document, Encrypt with Password. Give the client the password by phone, never in the same email. Word can't recover a lost password, so keep a copy in the firm's password manager.
How to share files through a portal instead of attachments
Consideration 4 also suggests "a well vetted and secure third-party cloud based file storage system to exchange documents normally attached to emails." A practice management portal is usually the simplest. If you share from your own suite, set the defaults so a careless click doesn't publish a file:
- Microsoft 365. In the SharePoint admin center, go to Policies, Sharing. Under File and folder links, make Specific people the default. If you allow Anyone links at all, make them expire after a set number of days and limit them to view only.
- Google Workspace. In the Admin console, go to Apps, Google Workspace, Drive and Docs, Sharing settings, Sharing options. With external sharing on, you can warn users before they share outside the firm and block link sharing.
Remove outside access when the matter closes. A settlement folder link that still works three years later is the kind of access point consideration 2 asks you to find.
How to label confidential email
Consideration 5 says to mark privileged communications "privileged and confidential," and adds that this "can also consist of something as simple as appending a message or 'disclaimer' to client emails, where such a disclaimer is accurate and appropriate for the communication." A footer on every lunch invitation is neither, so use two habits: a short footer on external mail, and "Privileged and confidential" typed at the top of messages that are.
- Microsoft 365. In the Exchange admin center, go to Mail flow, Rules, Add a rule, Apply disclaimers. Apply it when the recipient is outside the organization, with an exception for the disclaimer's own text so replies don't stack copies.
- Google Workspace. In the Admin console, go to Apps, Google Workspace, Gmail, Compliance, Append footer. Changes can take up to 24 hours.
Which Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace plans include these settings
On October 18, 2026 we read Opinion 477R in full, listed every specific safeguard it names in considerations 3 to 5, and checked the ones that live in the email and file service against Microsoft's and Google's current admin documentation. Firewalls, antivirus and updates belong to the computers, so they aren't in the table.
| Measure named in Opinion 477R | Microsoft 365 | Google Workspace |
|---|---|---|
| Multi-factor authentication | Security defaults, no extra license | 2-Step Verification |
| Encrypt sensitive transmissions | Business Premium; an add-on for Basic and Standard | Hosted S/MIME on Frontline Plus, Enterprise Plus and Education only |
| Password protection for attachments | Office file encryption | The same encrypted Office file, sent from Gmail |
| Secure cloud storage instead of attachments | SharePoint and OneDrive sharing defaults | Drive sharing options |
| Label confidential messages | Mail flow rule, Apply disclaimers | Gmail Append footer |
We found one gap. Encrypting the message itself is the only measure in the table that Microsoft's or Google's documentation ties to a higher plan. A firm on Microsoft 365 Business Standard or a Google Business edition that emails sensitive documents has three choices: upgrade, send through a portal, or encrypt the file.
How to train staff on email and file rules
Consideration 6 says lawyers "must establish policies and procedures, and periodically train employees, subordinates and others assisting in the delivery of legal services, in the use of reasonably secure methods of electronic communications with clients," and that supervising lawyers "must follow up to ensure these policies are being implemented."
For a small firm that is one page everyone signs: which matters get encryption or the portal, how to share a file, and no client documents sent to personal addresses. Go over it once a year, keep a list of who attended, and spot-check a few shared links each quarter.
How to check the vendors that carry client communications
Consideration 7 applies Rule 5.3 to the companies behind your email, storage and portal. It lists factors from Formal Opinion 08-451, including reference checks and credentials, the vendor's security policies and hiring practices, confidentiality agreements, its conflicts check, and whether you'd have a legal forum if it broke the agreement. It says the lawyer "must periodically reassess these factors."
Keep a list of every vendor that holds client email or files, where its security terms are, and the date you last reviewed them. Crashcart keeps that list for law firms, with where each vendor's agreement stands and itself included; the review and the decision to keep a vendor stay with you. Microsoft and Google belong on it too, and our guide to email security for small businesses covers the filtering and spoofing settings that sit alongside these steps.
ABA Formal Opinion 477R checklist
- Read your state's Rule 1.6 and search your state bar's opinions for "email," "cloud" and "encryption."
- Mark the matters that need more than ordinary email, and ask at intake which email address the client wants used.
- List every mailbox, storage location, device and account that holds client information, and who can reach it.
- Turn on MFA for everyone: security defaults in Microsoft 365, enforced 2-Step Verification in Google Workspace.
- Confirm updates, antivirus and disk encryption on every device that opens firm email.
- Decide how sensitive documents leave the office: encrypted email (check your plan), a portal, or a password-protected file with the password given by phone.
- Make specific people the default sharing link, make Anyone links expire, and remove outside access when matters close.
- Add an external disclaimer rule, and mark privileged messages "privileged and confidential."
- Write a one-page email and file policy, train everyone on it each year, and keep the attendance list.
- Keep a vendor list with each vendor's security terms, and review it every year.
This is general information, not legal advice. For your situation, ask your attorney.
More in this topic
Crashcart runs IT and security for small offices for $35 a computer a month. Start a 14-day free trial.